Review: My Real Name Is Hanna

My Real Name Is Hanna by Tara Lynn Masih
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

Many thanks to Netgalley, Mandel Vilar Press and Tara Lynn Masih for an ARC in exchange for an honest review. My opinions are 100% my own and independent of receiving an advanced copy.

First and foremost, I want to say that for the subject matter alone, this should get 5 stars. This is an account of a fictional character’s experience during the Holocaust. It is loosely based on the story of a real person, Esther Stermer, her extended family and four other families. If interested, there is a documentary film called “No Place on Earth” that relates the true story of what happened. I believe reading, hearing, listening to Holocaust stories are of the utmost importance. Documenting these first hand accounts are crucial as these survivors will soon no longer be with us to tell their stories. Masih relates this story in a way that is an appropriate entry point for children, or young adults, because it doesn’t get into the horrific details of what happened during that time. There are no concentration camps in this story. You do, however, get to know Hanna as a child, see how her life was like before the war contrasted against what she had to endure over years.

It was difficult to read this copy of the book because of the state I received it in. That can sometimes happen with ARC’s, there can be grammatical errors, certain parts may be rewritten, it is in an unfinished state. I had not yet received one in the condition this book was in, so it affected the reading for me. There were sentences that were dropped, left unfinished, paragraphs weren’t split where they should have been and extra text was inserted in each paragraph that didn’t belong there. Regardless, I believe it will be outstanding, once the completed version is released.

The story is told from 14 yr. old. Hanna’s perspective, from what I can tell it has an almost testimonial feel, an admission of what happened to her as a child. You can feel the raw emotion underneath her words and how difficult it is for her to talk about her experience. This is a matter of fact telling from a little girl who had to be so brave, with no drama. But because of the stark way the story is told, it juxtaposes how horrible it must have been. There is no way you can not be moved by what happened. You can feel her hunger pangs. You will wonder how people could do this to each other? You can appreciate how much the smallest kindness can mean to people who are fighting for their lives. As a teacher, this story is rich in lessons for students to learn from, many entry points for the child in to this story. This is something I will use and I strongly recommend.

Hanna lives in a rural town in the Ukraine, on a farm with her family. She is the eldest of three, with a brother and a sister, both of whom she loves dearly. Her family are observant Jews and she learns the traditions and the meaning behind them from both her father and her mother. She has friends and goes to school. They are not rich, but they do not want for anything. Birthdays are special and Hanna feels loved, safe and secure. Things change slowly, but they don’t fear because they have been taken over by the Russians, so now it is the Germans, it happens. They live in a remote village, so sometimes war doesn’t reach them, but of course this time it does. They don’t always hear the latest news, or realize where the trains are taking people, or what the smoke means, until they do. Food becomes scarce, they can no longer go to school, but it is not the first time their parents have had to scrimp and go hungry. Until this time it is different. Until it is too late to leave the country, until they are forced out of their homes. Hiding in the forest, it seems like things couldn’t possible get worse. Until they have to live in a cave. Of course, there is much more to the story. But it is important to hear it in Hanna’s words.

The most important thing is that they did survive the unthinkable. In the face of evil, they triumphed. They eventually left their home, but they continued to live and prospered. The human spirit is truly remarkable.


View all my reviews